[{"model":"openai/gpt-6.1-terra","provider":"OpenAI","run_id":"5e330a4f60f8b344","finished_at":"2026-10-27T12:55:21.897+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":false,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":77.06,"ai_low":75.4,"ai_high":78.65,"story_score":70.11904761904762,"intelligence_score":78.80357142857143,"prose_score":84.81249999999999,"overall_score":69.22237019697653,"human_score":63.28083524892913,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":73.16666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":72.72222222222223,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":72.43055555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":70.25,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":70.16666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":67.55555555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":64.54166666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":84.68055555555554,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":83.08333333333334,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":82.47222222222221,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":80.5,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":76.15277777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":75.73611111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":69,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":94.125,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":93.86111111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":85.625,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":78.77777777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":78.38888888888889,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":78.09722222222221,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":1,"price_out":5,"price_source":"live","blended_price":2.310069742059925,"value_score":65.58611928058944,"writer_cost":1.630238544,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":1094.5517636193247,"low":1032.3000468793282,"high":1156.8034803593212,"votes":122,"wins":74,"losses":41,"ties":7,"win_rate":63.52459016393443,"provisional":false}},{"model":"anthropic/claude-opus-5.5","provider":"Anthropic","run_id":"0e9aa081a724a7e4","finished_at":"2026-10-15T01:23:42.650+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":2,"ai_score":84.07,"ai_low":83.35000000000001,"ai_high":84.75,"story_score":81.05357142857143,"intelligence_score":86.21428571428571,"prose_score":86.1875,"overall_score":66.68702686595438,"human_score":54.53343763373347,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":83.04166666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":82.58333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":82.41666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":81.91666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":81.22222222222221,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":78.80555555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":77.38888888888889,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":91.19444444444443,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":89.04166666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":88.38888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":86,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":84.73611111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":82.88888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":81.25,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":91.45833333333334,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":86.84722222222221,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":85.43055555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":85.15277777777777,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":84.34722222222223,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":83.88888888888889,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":4,"price_out":20,"price_source":"live","blended_price":8.930857327044645,"value_score":57.178095351500176,"writer_cost":13.440834,"writer_cost_complete":false,"human":{"rating":1031.5883023666656,"low":971.5122896727307,"high":1091.6643150606005,"votes":123,"wins":59,"losses":48,"ties":16,"win_rate":54.47154471544715,"provisional":false}},{"model":"google/gemini-4-argon","provider":"Google","run_id":"c87e71ad62cc216d","finished_at":"2026-10-15T01:41:33.061+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":73.72,"ai_low":71.85,"ai_high":75.35,"story_score":70.12698412698413,"intelligence_score":78.30952380952381,"prose_score":73.51851851851852,"overall_score":65.6610647592775,"human_score":59.39101622137078,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"World Building","score":76.33333333333334,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":74.625,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":72.86111111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":68.33333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":67.98611111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":66.04166666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":64.70833333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":85.51388888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":84.88888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":82.61111111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":75.5,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":74.08333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":73.93055555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":71.63888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":76.52777777777777,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":76.27777777777779,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":73.31944444444444,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":72.48611111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":71.44444444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":71.05555555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":2,"price_out":10,"price_source":"live","blended_price":4.167480454250431,"value_score":59.46232904291795,"writer_cost":3.506646924,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":1066.0394539262793,"low":1006.1003144553925,"high":1125.9785933971662,"votes":127,"wins":65,"losses":41,"ties":21,"win_rate":59.4488188976378,"provisional":false}},{"model":"anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5","provider":"Anthropic","run_id":"2fe2ad88b89ba2eb","finished_at":"2026-10-16T14:13:43.739+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":5,"ai_score":81.17,"ai_low":80.25,"ai_high":81.89999999999999,"story_score":78.15079365079364,"intelligence_score":82.9920634920635,"prose_score":84.60648148148148,"overall_score":64.28706837427431,"human_score":52.35488027105684,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":81.43055555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":78.91666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":78.16666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":77.90277777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":77.88888888888889,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":77.77777777777779,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":74.97222222222221,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":89,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":87.1111111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":85.23611111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":83.58333333333334,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":82.34722222222223,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":77,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":76.66666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":90.34722222222221,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":84.65277777777779,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":84.36111111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":83.56944444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":82.61111111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":82.09722222222223,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":2,"price_out":10,"price_source":"live","blended_price":4.727996165331651,"value_score":57.540297217911146,"writer_cost":7.43120334,"writer_cost_complete":false,"human":{"rating":1016.375499245777,"low":958.4932488783613,"high":1074.2577496131926,"votes":132,"wins":63,"losses":57,"ties":12,"win_rate":52.27272727272727,"provisional":false}},{"model":"meta/muse-wonder","provider":"Meta","run_id":"c33df9567dbe2dae","finished_at":"2026-10-15T08:14:07.250+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":79.39,"ai_low":78.25,"ai_high":80.39999999999999,"story_score":77.22619047619048,"intelligence_score":81.07738095238095,"prose_score":81.02546296296296,"overall_score":64.16086863460212,"human_score":53.533711833684315,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":80.88888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":78.43055555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":77.41666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":77.38888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":77,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":74.75,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":74.70833333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":85.65277777777779,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":85.52777777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":83.58333333333334,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":83.11111111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":81.43055555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":75.40277777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":72.83333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":87.31944444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":82.48611111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":80.875,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":79.94444444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":79.59722222222223,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":75.93055555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":4,"price_out":20,"price_source":"live","blended_price":11.605876494023905,"value_score":53.514089188282284,"writer_cost":12.736153584,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":1024.595750163513,"low":963.8850836475838,"high":1085.3064166794422,"votes":120,"wins":55,"losses":47,"ties":18,"win_rate":53.333333333333336,"provisional":false}},{"model":"openai/gpt-6-astra","provider":"OpenAI","run_id":"596007dd82e0ceac","finished_at":"2026-10-15T23:19:26.376+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":false,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":83,"ai_low":82.4,"ai_high":83.69999999999999,"story_score":78.12698412698413,"intelligence_score":84.39880952380952,"prose_score":87.38657407407408,"overall_score":64.14212634581293,"human_score":51.18501436824202,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":82.5,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":81.98611111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":79.76388888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":77.13888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":76.75,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":75.38888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":73.36111111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":88.27777777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":87.97222222222223,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":85.91666666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":85.77777777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":83.7361111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":82.27777777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":76.83333333333334,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":94.44444444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":93.3611111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":84.88888888888889,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":84.66666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":84.33333333333334,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":82.625,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":10,"price_out":50,"price_source":"live","blended_price":22.02366982850682,"value_score":50.713229469448564,"writer_cost":14.160130875,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":1008.2358654871928,"low":948.6090497899628,"high":1067.8626811844226,"votes":124,"wins":57,"losses":54,"ties":13,"win_rate":51.20967741935484,"provisional":false}},{"model":"anthropic/claude-fable-5.1","provider":"Anthropic","run_id":"2e4b098807294495","finished_at":"2026-10-14T23:46:21.332+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":81.86,"ai_low":80.85000000000001,"ai_high":83,"story_score":79.03174603174602,"intelligence_score":83.90079365079364,"prose_score":85.1087962962963,"overall_score":63.63474037675796,"human_score":50.73421235632499,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":82.30555555555554,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":80,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":79.5,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":79.125,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":78.29166666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":78.25,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":75.75,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":88.83333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":87.83333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":87.19444444444446,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":84.41666666666666,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":82.625,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":78.56944444444444,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":77.83333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":90.83333333333334,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":86.34722222222223,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":84.33333333333334,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":84.01388888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":83.20833333333333,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":81.91666666666666,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":10,"price_out":50,"price_source":"live","blended_price":21.966170919086792,"value_score":50.21719679145964,"writer_cost":32.0003145,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":1005.102196743429,"low":946.1754102729512,"high":1064.0289832139067,"votes":127,"wins":58,"losses":56,"ties":13,"win_rate":50.78740157480315,"provisional":false}},{"model":"openai/gpt-6-astra-pro","provider":"OpenAI","run_id":"27b013e741a6ae41","finished_at":"2026-10-15T23:43:43.632+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":false,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":83.16,"ai_low":82.5,"ai_high":83.80000000000001,"story_score":78.18650793650794,"intelligence_score":84.78373015873015,"prose_score":87.37268518518518,"overall_score":63.12477355401432,"human_score":49.35351368349829,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":81.93055555555557,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":81.83333333333334,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":80.26388888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":77.875,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":76.08333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":75.65277777777779,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":73.66666666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":88.95833333333331,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":88.83333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":86.16666666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":85.83333333333334,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":84.02777777777779,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":82.66666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":77,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":94.41666666666666,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":93.33333333333334,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":85.11111111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":84.44444444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":84.40277777777779,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":82.52777777777779,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":10,"price_out":50,"price_source":"live","blended_price":17.130397548747844,"value_score":50.787099135553575,"writer_cost":43.17840846,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":995.507502602071,"low":937.8681302678716,"high":1053.1468749362705,"votes":133,"wins":57,"losses":60,"ties":16,"win_rate":48.87218045112782,"provisional":false}},{"model":"moonshotai/kimi-k3.1-pro","provider":"Moonshot AI","run_id":"ef8a81e9fb1b6a05","finished_at":"2026-10-27T13:55:01.173+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":false,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":81.5,"ai_low":80.5,"ai_high":82.35,"story_score":77.10714285714286,"intelligence_score":83.73214285714286,"prose_score":85.1550925925926,"overall_score":62.98752206108563,"human_score":50.02478324113918,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":80.16666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":80.125,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":79.34722222222221,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":76.90277777777779,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":75.16666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":74.61111111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":73.43055555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":89.41666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":88.15277777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":86.5,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":84.41666666666666,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":81.8611111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":79.94444444444446,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":75.83333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":92.52777777777779,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":89.56944444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":83.55555555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":82.29166666666666,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":81.5,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":81.48611111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":2,"price_out":10,"price_source":"live","blended_price":6.702562278020893,"value_score":54.72511348112331,"writer_cost":8.902750428,"writer_cost_complete":false,"human":{"rating":1000.17221161203,"low":941.4954251185767,"high":1058.8489981054831,"votes":128,"wins":60,"losses":60,"ties":8,"win_rate":50,"provisional":false}},{"model":"openai/gpt-6-sol","provider":"OpenAI","run_id":"ab472ce657210656","finished_at":"2026-10-15T04:59:11.134+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":false,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":77.81,"ai_low":76.65,"ai_high":79.05,"story_score":71.1031746031746,"intelligence_score":79.48214285714286,"prose_score":84.87962962962963,"overall_score":62.92254945016278,"human_score":52.379734092422964,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":74.47222222222223,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":73.75,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":72.01388888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":71.66666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":69.33333333333334,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":69.05555555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":67.43055555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":84.66666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":82.69444444444444,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":82.33333333333334,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":81.80555555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":78,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":75.79166666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":71.08333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":93.48611111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":92.97222222222223,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":85.41666666666666,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":79.97222222222221,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":78.9861111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":78.44444444444446,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":2,"price_out":10,"price_source":"live","blended_price":4.991830840519866,"value_score":55.93995085143499,"writer_cost":3.647406411,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":1016.5485892975303,"low":958.7016610157934,"high":1074.395517579267,"votes":132,"wins":64,"losses":58,"ties":10,"win_rate":52.27272727272727,"provisional":false}},{"model":"google/gemini-4-carbon","provider":"Google","run_id":"a8a14777081423cc","finished_at":"2026-11-11T17:26:03.884+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":78.42,"ai_low":77.4,"ai_high":79.55,"story_score":75.79166666666666,"intelligence_score":82.41865079365077,"prose_score":77.51620370370371,"overall_score":62.56493840285309,"human_score":51.25070201180983,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"World Building","score":81.75,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":80.11111111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":76.58333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":75.33333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":73.13888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":71.84722222222221,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":71.77777777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":88.75,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":88.69444444444443,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":86.02777777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":81.5,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":78.54166666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":76.75,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":76.66666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":79.06944444444446,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":77.93055555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":77.81944444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":77.26388888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":76.75,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":76.26388888888889,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":2,"price_out":10,"price_source":"live","blended_price":6.324969629068807,"value_score":54.554353958065434,"writer_cost":9.185165352,"writer_cost_complete":false,"human":{"rating":1008.6925810073983,"low":909.0329236331374,"high":1108.3522383816592,"votes":43,"wins":19,"losses":18,"ties":6,"win_rate":51.162790697674424,"provisional":false}},{"model":"anthropic/claude-fable-5.2","provider":"Anthropic","run_id":"b5be9c0026a5bc06","finished_at":"2026-11-09T20:15:50.429+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":87.57,"ai_low":86.85000000000001,"ai_high":88.2,"story_score":84.05753968253968,"intelligence_score":89.29563492063492,"prose_score":90.48842592592592,"overall_score":62.12780656573942,"human_score":44.69013836794313,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":86.58333333333334,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":85.91666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":85.41666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":85.16666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":82.625,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":81.41666666666666,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":81.27777777777779,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":94.16666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":91.95833333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":91.94444444444444,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":88.33333333333334,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":87.41666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":87.08333333333331,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":84.16666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":94.63888888888889,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":92.41666666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":91.16666666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":89.15277777777777,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":88.47222222222221,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":87.08333333333334,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":8,"price_out":40,"price_source":"live","blended_price":23.02103152419742,"value_score":48.50655877018218,"writer_cost":41.95136088,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":962.9636509228161,"low":862.7120955533787,"high":1063.2152062922535,"votes":43,"wins":16,"losses":21,"ties":6,"win_rate":44.18604651162791,"provisional":false}},{"model":"meta/muse-spark-1.3","provider":"Meta","run_id":"0916419599ab0416","finished_at":"2026-10-15T08:37:36.813+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":72.24,"ai_low":70.5,"ai_high":73.85,"story_score":68.52579365079366,"intelligence_score":75.59920634920636,"prose_score":74.53935185185186,"overall_score":61.84351613942795,"human_score":54.028600532203534,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"World Building","score":71,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":70.25,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":69.69444444444446,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":68.95833333333334,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":67.72222222222223,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":66.33333333333334,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":65.72222222222223,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":83.04166666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":82.1111111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":81.6388888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":76,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":73.44444444444446,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":68.25,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":64.70833333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":85.44444444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":80.68055555555557,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":72.41666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":70.61111111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":69.38888888888889,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":68.69444444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":1.25,"price_out":4.25,"price_source":"live","blended_price":2.8371245481028016,"value_score":57.31473212455547,"writer_cost":2.678713191,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":1028.0543974525867,"low":969.1753634241859,"high":1086.9334314809876,"votes":128,"wins":64,"losses":54,"ties":10,"win_rate":53.90625,"provisional":false}},{"model":"google/gemini-3.7-flash","provider":"Google","run_id":"9b62fe0af888385f","finished_at":"2026-10-15T03:48:21.698+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":64.43,"ai_low":62.300000000000004,"ai_high":66.44999999999999,"story_score":60.84325396825396,"intelligence_score":69.82142857142857,"prose_score":63.63888888888889,"overall_score":61.6365045944504,"human_score":58.706674324084,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"World Building","score":68.16666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":64.16666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":63.861111111111114,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":60.986111111111114,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":58.833333333333336,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":55.583333333333336,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":54.30555555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":79.86111111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":77,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":73.66666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":65.84722222222223,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":65.5,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":64.375,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":62.5,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":68.23611111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":66.43055555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":64.75,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":62.94444444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":61.986111111111114,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":57.48611111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":0.75,"price_out":3.75,"price_source":"live","blended_price":1.9890972292650217,"value_score":58.64994447008773,"writer_cost":1.867791123,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":1061.1230469141667,"low":1000.8724857228998,"high":1121.3736081054337,"votes":125,"wins":66,"losses":44,"ties":15,"win_rate":58.8,"provisional":false}},{"model":"openai/gpt-6-luna","provider":"OpenAI","run_id":"ba2c83909b8ce8b5","finished_at":"2026-10-15T04:44:03.060+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":false,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":66.9,"ai_low":64.80000000000001,"ai_high":68.75,"story_score":60.6468253968254,"intelligence_score":70.2579365079365,"prose_score":72.61342592592594,"overall_score":61.098490891357926,"human_score":56.20146409582581,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":63.94444444444445,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":62.583333333333336,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":62.06944444444444,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":61.68055555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":59.66666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":59.52777777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":55.05555555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":77.66666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":75.38888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":74.36111111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":71.75,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":67.51388888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":62.958333333333336,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":62.16666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":87.31944444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":82.09722222222223,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":68.125,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":67.61111111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":66.27777777777779,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":64.25,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":0.09999999999999999,"price_out":0.5,"price_source":"live","blended_price":0.26549667098863705,"value_score":66.85790009218603,"writer_cost":0.2106542097,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":1043.315214515676,"low":983.96549046891,"high":1102.6649385624419,"votes":127,"wins":67,"losses":51,"ties":9,"win_rate":56.2992125984252,"provisional":false}},{"model":"anthropic/claude-opus-4.8","provider":"Anthropic","run_id":"faf4de057efecbde","finished_at":"2026-10-15T02:26:17.360+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":false,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":72.25,"ai_low":70.9,"ai_high":73.65,"story_score":69.73412698412697,"intelligence_score":76.35119047619047,"prose_score":72.12037037037037,"overall_score":60.83504211241481,"human_score":52.298923802878306,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":72.34722222222223,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":71.51388888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":69.81944444444444,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":69.41666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":69.13888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":68.66666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":67.23611111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":83.95833333333331,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":80.19444444444444,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":78.52777777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":74.55555555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":73.66666666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":72.38888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":71.16666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":79.08333333333333,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":74.875,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":73.75,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":72.66666666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":68.05555555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":64.29166666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":5,"price_out":25,"price_source":"live","blended_price":9.841781964311537,"value_score":50.90430471834341,"writer_cost":12.60057645,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":1015.9858298973656,"low":955.8251135323603,"high":1076.146546262371,"votes":122,"wins":54,"losses":49,"ties":19,"win_rate":52.04918032786885,"provisional":false}},{"model":"aion-labs/aion-3.5","provider":"AionLabs","run_id":"71e45319eaf40906","finished_at":"2026-10-14T23:44:56.150+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":71.22,"ai_low":69.25,"ai_high":73.05,"story_score":68.83928571428571,"intelligence_score":74.22222222222221,"prose_score":71.4050925925926,"overall_score":60.810994536379155,"human_score":53.23685376874481,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":71.02777777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":70.41666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":69.80555555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":68.66666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":68.36111111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":67.25,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":66.34722222222221,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":82.08333333333331,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":79.13888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":77.25,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":73.48611111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":71.08333333333333,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":69.66666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":66.84722222222221,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":79.33333333333334,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":72.75,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":72.02777777777777,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":71.98611111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":68.52777777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":63.80555555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":3,"price_out":6,"price_source":"live","blended_price":4.4080877321842005,"value_score":54.368492241407566,"writer_cost":4.95911889,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":1022.5234633734565,"low":963.2664357724803,"high":1081.7804909744325,"votes":126,"wins":59,"losses":51,"ties":16,"win_rate":53.17460317460318,"provisional":false}},{"model":"openai/gpt-6.1-sol","provider":"OpenAI","run_id":"6c3d97d59dda21cb","finished_at":"2026-10-14T23:45:31.141+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":false,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":80.95,"ai_low":79.85000000000001,"ai_high":81.89999999999999,"story_score":75.51587301587303,"intelligence_score":82.97420634920636,"prose_score":85.5625,"overall_score":60.4551543041732,"human_score":46.254126221241044,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":79.26388888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":78.16666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":77.41666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":75.23611111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":74.16666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":73.5,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":70.86111111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":87.55555555555557,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":87.41666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":84.77777777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":84.66666666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":81.40277777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":80.41666666666669,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":74.58333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":93.83333333333333,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":92.83333333333333,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":82.40277777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":82.375,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":81.11111111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":80.81944444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":2,"price_out":10,"price_source":"live","blended_price":4.368107417429297,"value_score":54.052221207244855,"writer_cost":2.742382071,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":973.9221413293046,"low":914.7987346542909,"high":1033.0455480043183,"votes":127,"wins":54,"losses":65,"ties":8,"win_rate":45.66929133858268,"provisional":false}},{"model":"google/gemini-3.8-flash","provider":"Google","run_id":"8079e0728faff252","finished_at":"2026-10-14T23:45:16.193+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":68.92,"ai_low":67.05,"ai_high":70.75,"story_score":66.72222222222221,"intelligence_score":73.16666666666667,"prose_score":67.82175925925925,"overall_score":60.05781485414529,"human_score":53.28347228777301,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"World Building","score":72.91666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":68.79166666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":68.63888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":66.58333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":64.5,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":63.236111111111114,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":62.388888888888886,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":80.88888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":79.38888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":76.44444444444444,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":71.05555555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":69.66666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":68.91666666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":65.80555555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":70.33333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":68.80555555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":67.91666666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":67.81944444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":67.69444444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":64.36111111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":0.8250000000000001,"price_out":4.125,"price_source":"live","blended_price":2.475652654418701,"value_score":56.12091774327868,"writer_cost":2.88376419375,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":1022.8487851406899,"low":962.634020872407,"high":1083.0635494089727,"votes":122,"wins":59,"losses":51,"ties":12,"win_rate":53.278688524590166,"provisional":false}},{"model":"moonshotai/kimi-k3","provider":"Moonshot AI","run_id":"90413951c1be67e1","finished_at":"2026-10-15T04:27:38.432+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":false,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":72.35,"ai_low":70.9,"ai_high":73.75,"story_score":70.86706349206348,"intelligence_score":75.56944444444444,"prose_score":71.53703703703705,"overall_score":60.00743344675076,"human_score":51.08855750825304,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":73.72222222222221,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":73.70833333333334,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":71.5,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":71,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":69.06944444444446,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":68.66666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":68.40277777777777,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":81.7222222222222,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":81.36111111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":78.44444444444444,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":75.40277777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":74.25,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":69.25,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":68.55555555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":77.56944444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":74.30555555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":73.125,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":70.91666666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":69.48611111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":63.81944444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":0.192,"price_out":16,"price_source":"live","blended_price":9.049357867605341,"value_score":50.44125581431169,"writer_cost":13.07767415724,"writer_cost_complete":false,"human":{"rating":1007.5652677255916,"low":948.1600094652744,"high":1066.9705259859088,"votes":125,"wins":61,"losses":59,"ties":5,"win_rate":50.8,"provisional":false}},{"model":"aion-labs/aion-3.5-mini","provider":"AionLabs","run_id":"4bfbd627c60f25a3","finished_at":"2026-10-14T23:50:21.757+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":71.56,"ai_low":69.15,"ai_high":73.7,"story_score":69.7579365079365,"intelligence_score":73.76984126984128,"prose_score":71.29398148148148,"overall_score":58.073778193499614,"human_score":48.69103023431593,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":71.65277777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":71.19444444444444,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":71.18055555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":71.08333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":68.27777777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":67.75,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":67.16666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":80.66666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":79.30555555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":78.58333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":74.125,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":70.08333333333333,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":67.5,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":66.125,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":77.875,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":71.81944444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":71.68055555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":71.29166666666666,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":70.75,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":64.34722222222221,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":0.7,"price_out":1.4,"price_source":"live","blended_price":1.0389478102311651,"value_score":57.90784087286426,"writer_cost":3.2587135218,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":990.9022676710536,"low":933.0449331515252,"high":1048.759602190582,"votes":132,"wins":59,"losses":63,"ties":10,"win_rate":48.484848484848484,"provisional":false}},{"model":"aion-labs/aion-3.0","provider":"AionLabs","run_id":"620d67495f0cd1e9","finished_at":"2026-10-14T23:41:15.251+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":54.2,"ai_low":52.05,"ai_high":56.4,"story_score":47.90277777777777,"intelligence_score":61.11904761904761,"prose_score":56.86574074074073,"overall_score":58.02163899844967,"human_score":58.8682960379805,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":51.222222222222214,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":51.083333333333336,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":49.319444444444436,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":48.166666666666664,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":48.083333333333336,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":47.611111111111114,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":39.833333333333336,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":75.66666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":70.16666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":69.25,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":55.5,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":54.66666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":51.833333333333336,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":50.75,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":79.70833333333333,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":71.97222222222221,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":51.208333333333336,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":49.638888888888886,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":47.08333333333333,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":41.58333333333333,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":3,"price_out":6,"price_source":"live","blended_price":4.363591992075277,"value_score":51.62319763766004,"writer_cost":3.3386282325,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":1062.281905524319,"low":1002.0257639365512,"high":1122.5380471120866,"votes":125,"wins":67,"losses":45,"ties":13,"win_rate":58.8,"provisional":false}},{"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash-1017","provider":"DeepSeek","run_id":"e62b50bffb691eb1","finished_at":"2026-10-19T13:59:12.544+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":70.55,"ai_low":68.45,"ai_high":72.6,"story_score":66.8611111111111,"intelligence_score":71.63095238095238,"prose_score":74.75462962962962,"overall_score":57.701426698173165,"human_score":48.68943691318103,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":69.83333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":68.45833333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":67.66666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":66.68055555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":66.01388888888889,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":65.375,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":64,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":80.51388888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":76.72222222222223,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":73.52777777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":71.56944444444446,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":70.41666666666666,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":65.91666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":62.75,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":84.625,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":77.55555555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":73.51388888888889,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":71.98611111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":70.86111111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":69.98611111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":0.02,"price_out":0.108,"price_source":"live","blended_price":0.05941712791475448,"value_score":67.70142669817317,"writer_cost":0.1549712439,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":990.8911885393767,"low":931.2088688089334,"high":1050.57350826982,"votes":124,"wins":56,"losses":61,"ties":7,"win_rate":47.983870967741936,"provisional":false}},{"model":"qwen/qwen3.8-max-prime","provider":"Qwen","run_id":"186e2fe6187bacb5","finished_at":"2026-10-15T10:15:33.124+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":65.26,"ai_low":62.55,"ai_high":67.55,"story_score":61.835317460317455,"intelligence_score":70.74603174603173,"prose_score":64.49999999999999,"overall_score":56.20881338407139,"human_score":49.043458814722165,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"World Building","score":64.58333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":63.69444444444444,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":63.66666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":63.05555555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":60.8611111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":60.5,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":56.486111111111114,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":81.31944444444444,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":80.61111111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":74.38888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":67.41666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":64.08333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":63.916666666666664,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":63.486111111111114,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":76.80555555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":66.625,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":64.625,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":63.65277777777778,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":63.55555555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":51.73611111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":4,"price_out":12,"price_source":"live","blended_price":10.413748202787414,"value_score":46.03274265880028,"writer_cost":30.31749864,"writer_cost_complete":false,"human":{"rating":993.352460010957,"low":933.735982052515,"high":1052.968937969399,"votes":124,"wins":53,"losses":56,"ties":15,"win_rate":48.79032258064516,"provisional":false}},{"model":"anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5","provider":"Anthropic","run_id":"b4af077fd90aafe5","finished_at":"2026-10-14T23:49:37.708+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":68.49,"ai_low":66.25,"ai_high":70.6,"story_score":63.25198412698412,"intelligence_score":68.72023809523809,"prose_score":76.68981481481481,"overall_score":55.68240851801984,"human_score":46.573635007987214,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":67.13888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":64.91666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":64.05555555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":63.59722222222223,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":62.236111111111114,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":60.83333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":59.98611111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":77.41666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":76.41666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":70.51388888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":69.25,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":67.58333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":60.25,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":59.6111111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":88.04166666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":82.94444444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":75.80555555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":73.13888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":72.05555555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":68.15277777777779,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":0.09999999999999999,"price_out":0.5,"price_source":"live","blended_price":0.23775188848932277,"value_score":61.92116876530136,"writer_cost":0.370855386,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":976.1538034234709,"low":916.6207680953261,"high":1035.6868387516156,"votes":125,"wins":52,"losses":61,"ties":12,"win_rate":46.400000000000006,"provisional":false}},{"model":"xiaomi/mimo-v2.6-flash","provider":"Xiaomi","run_id":"35dd85e7f310cd70","finished_at":"2026-10-15T07:17:40.100+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":false,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":58.55,"ai_low":56.050000000000004,"ai_high":60.8,"story_score":54.29365079365079,"intelligence_score":61.34126984126984,"prose_score":61.90046296296296,"overall_score":55.33925322771708,"human_score":52.41931313966957,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":57.736111111111114,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":56.916666666666664,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":54.013888888888886,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":53.152777777777786,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":53.083333333333336,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":52.90277777777778,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":52.25,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":69.88888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":68.125,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":65.52777777777779,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":61.06944444444444,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":58.166666666666664,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":53.5,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":53.11111111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":76.375,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":66.44444444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":62.40277777777777,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":60.8611111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":55.52777777777778,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":49.79166666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":0.14,"price_out":0.28,"price_source":"live","blended_price":0.18393386118989616,"value_score":62.69263635000631,"writer_cost":0.116174650878,"writer_cost_complete":false,"human":{"rating":1016.8242475656903,"low":957.5706006658935,"high":1076.0778944654871,"votes":126,"wins":60,"losses":54,"ties":12,"win_rate":52.38095238095239,"provisional":false}},{"model":"z-ai/glm-5.3-flash","provider":"Z.ai","run_id":"7218559006e3cf33","finished_at":"2026-10-15T05:48:23.367+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":false,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":70.72,"ai_low":68.94999999999999,"ai_high":72.30000000000001,"story_score":68.87896825396827,"intelligence_score":72.44246031746032,"prose_score":71.7013888888889,"overall_score":55.19657089656961,"human_score":44.4167385313197,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":71.375,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":70.25,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":69.84722222222223,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":69.59722222222223,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":68.875,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":66.625,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":65.58333333333334,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":80.33333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":78.11111111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":76.66666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":72.43055555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":69.5,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":66.83333333333334,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":63.22222222222223,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":78.83333333333333,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":73.06944444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":71.20833333333334,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":70.80555555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":69.97222222222221,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":66.31944444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":0.0399,"price_out":0.0784,"price_source":"live","blended_price":0.06218100947074434,"value_score":65.19657089656961,"writer_cost":0.4443850039365,"writer_cost_complete":false,"human":{"rating":961.0410557161348,"low":901.4649295434551,"high":1020.6171818888145,"votes":126,"wins":48,"losses":63,"ties":15,"win_rate":44.047619047619044,"provisional":false}},{"model":"minimax/minimax-m3","provider":"MiniMax","run_id":"67508f0efde36b51","finished_at":"2026-10-19T14:27:50.841+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":false,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":57.84,"ai_low":55.35,"ai_high":60.199999999999996,"story_score":53.202380952380956,"intelligence_score":59.66865079365079,"prose_score":63.59027777777778,"overall_score":55.1039690587476,"human_score":52.48495504500262,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":55.72222222222222,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":55.263888888888886,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":54.430555555555564,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":53.833333333333336,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":51.69444444444444,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":51.55555555555555,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":49.916666666666664,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":67.83333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":65.11111111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":64.76388888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":58.722222222222214,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":56.75,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":53.33333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":51.16666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":80.02777777777779,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":70.51388888888889,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":63.20833333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":58.95833333333333,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":54.91666666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":53.916666666666664,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":0.3,"price_out":1.2,"price_source":"live","blended_price":0.748779168469758,"value_score":56.360431523355224,"writer_cost":0.78769677888,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":1017.2814740223303,"low":958.0570465461757,"high":1076.505901498485,"votes":126,"wins":59,"losses":53,"ties":14,"win_rate":52.38095238095239,"provisional":false}},{"model":"x-ai/grok-4.7","provider":"xAI","run_id":"cb0c87bc5e60c881","finished_at":"2026-10-14T23:44:20.965+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":74.51,"ai_low":73.2,"ai_high":75.7,"story_score":70.38888888888889,"intelligence_score":78.09325396825398,"prose_score":77.6388888888889,"overall_score":55.04604477076017,"human_score":41.04102699888598,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":73.70833333333334,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":72.58333333333334,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":70.66666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":70.56944444444444,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":69.09722222222223,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":68.66666666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":67.43055555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":85.75,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":84.91666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":81.75,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":80.94444444444446,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":75.33333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":71.625,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":66.33333333333334,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":87.625,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":77.86111111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":77.77777777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":76.38888888888889,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":74.72222222222223,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":71.45833333333334,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":2,"price_out":6,"price_source":"live","blended_price":3.5843802209013056,"value_score":49.501904049138076,"writer_cost":3.9146481,"writer_cost_complete":false,"human":{"rating":937.0673239615912,"low":876.8855535230138,"high":997.2490944001687,"votes":126,"wins":44,"losses":68,"ties":14,"win_rate":40.476190476190474,"provisional":false}},{"model":"xiaomi/mimo-v2.6-pro","provider":"Xiaomi","run_id":"e31bca42626befe4","finished_at":"2026-10-15T07:52:43.491+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":65.31,"ai_low":63.25,"ai_high":67.25,"story_score":61.42658730158729,"intelligence_score":68.63690476190476,"prose_score":68.14120370370371,"overall_score":54.61676410374815,"human_score":46.55434008473017,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":64.15277777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":63.722222222222214,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":61.333333333333336,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":60.80555555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":60.513888888888886,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":60.125,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":59.333333333333336,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":76.25,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":75.38888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":73.47222222222223,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":67.38888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":66.75,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":60.83333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":60.375,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":81.30555555555557,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":72.09722222222223,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":67.05555555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":66.54166666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":63.44444444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":58.40277777777778,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":0.435,"price_out":0.87,"price_source":"live","blended_price":0.599909840353295,"value_score":56.83590424623249,"writer_cost":0.401351441832,"writer_cost_complete":false,"human":{"rating":976.0190923934263,"low":916.6937392656844,"high":1035.3444455211682,"votes":126,"wins":53,"losses":63,"ties":10,"win_rate":46.03174603174603,"provisional":false}},{"model":"z-ai/glm-5.3","provider":"Z.ai","run_id":"9e0013a7383ef622","finished_at":"2026-10-19T20:29:14.237+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":false,"manual_responses":1,"ai_score":72.72,"ai_low":70.9,"ai_high":74.5,"story_score":71.26984126984128,"intelligence_score":74.73412698412697,"prose_score":72.79166666666667,"overall_score":52.99571071831258,"human_score":39.404557546393974,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"World Building","score":73.41666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":72.41666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":72.22222222222223,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":71.76388888888889,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":71.5,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":69.90277777777779,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":67.66666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":82.63888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":79.69444444444444,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":79.08333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":74.95833333333334,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":72.33333333333333,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":68.83333333333334,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":65.59722222222221,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":78.20833333333333,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":74.20833333333333,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":72.51388888888889,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":72.15277777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":70.52777777777779,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":69.13888888888889,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":0.08399999999999999,"price_out":3.5999999999999996,"price_source":"live","blended_price":2.833625323045115,"value_score":48.47228646841266,"writer_cost":8.76832674894,"writer_cost_complete":false,"human":{"rating":925.2425977846026,"low":864.9234880253113,"high":985.5617075438939,"votes":127,"wins":42,"losses":70,"ties":15,"win_rate":38.976377952755904,"provisional":false}},{"model":"google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite","provider":"Google","run_id":"c8560326be746aff","finished_at":"2026-10-15T03:57:38.682+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":false,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":52.11,"ai_low":49.85,"ai_high":54.349999999999994,"story_score":49.80357142857143,"intelligence_score":56.93452380952381,"prose_score":49.65277777777778,"overall_score":52.770149875773015,"human_score":52.39601698872222,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"World Building","score":54.333333333333336,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":52.84722222222222,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":52.05555555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":51.69444444444444,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":47.666666666666664,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":46.416666666666664,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":43.61111111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":71.55555555555554,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":63.47222222222222,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":57.888888888888886,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":54.58333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":54.09722222222222,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":53.111111111111114,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":43.833333333333336,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":55.34722222222222,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":51.30555555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":51.25,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":50.05555555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":48.04166666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":41.916666666666664,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":0.3,"price_out":2.5,"price_source":"live","blended_price":0.9340102109771858,"value_score":53.06663363438422,"writer_cost":0.6830554104,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":1016.6619930998423,"low":957.9089980869104,"high":1075.4149881127744,"votes":128,"wins":60,"losses":54,"ties":14,"win_rate":52.34375,"provisional":false}},{"model":"meta/muse-ember","provider":"Meta","run_id":"649a2228f890cffe","finished_at":"2026-11-09T20:28:55.722+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":69.32,"ai_low":66.55,"ai_high":71.65,"story_score":64.16468253968254,"intelligence_score":72.21626984126983,"prose_score":75.4699074074074,"overall_score":52.33367610512472,"human_score":39.87827190360292,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":67.95833333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":65.79166666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":64.44444444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":64.33333333333334,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":63.25,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":62.51388888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":60.861111111111114,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":80.08333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":80.08333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":77.83333333333333,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":77.69444444444444,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":70.33333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":61.40277777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":58.083333333333336,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":88.75,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":84.23611111111111,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":72.72222222222223,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":72.125,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":69.08333333333333,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":65.90277777777777,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":0.09999999999999999,"price_out":0.5,"price_source":"live","blended_price":0.3853427874483665,"value_score":56.47520375906389,"writer_cost":0.66010592736,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":928.6819500236383,"low":831.1863107212681,"high":1026.1775893260085,"votes":47,"wins":15,"losses":25,"ties":7,"win_rate":39.361702127659576,"provisional":false}},{"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash","provider":"DeepSeek","run_id":"4a581a1fd7210cd8","finished_at":"2026-10-15T03:02:55.979+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":60.15,"ai_low":57.45,"ai_high":63.05,"story_score":55.396825396825406,"intelligence_score":64.48214285714285,"prose_score":62.4675925925926,"overall_score":52.112813289075206,"human_score":45.71657153117472,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"World Building","score":58.166666666666664,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":57.79166666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":57.33333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":56.55555555555555,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":54.986111111111114,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":53,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":49.94444444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":78.61111111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":70.38888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":68.55555555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":61.40277777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":58.083333333333336,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":57.5,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":56.833333333333336,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":81.25,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":71.56944444444446,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":58.81944444444444,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":58.375,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":54.875,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":49.91666666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":0.050699999999999995,"price_out":0.20279999999999998,"price_source":"live","blended_price":0.12300600405078677,"value_score":61.213550185861166,"writer_cost":0.4316758040232,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":970.1625536593401,"low":911.4489118914487,"high":1028.8761954272316,"votes":129,"wins":51,"losses":63,"ties":15,"win_rate":45.348837209302324,"provisional":false}},{"model":"aion-labs/aion-3.0-mini","provider":"AionLabs","run_id":"6bb84c83d764dff6","finished_at":"2026-10-15T02:49:22.771+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":46.64,"ai_low":44.85,"ai_high":48.550000000000004,"story_score":39.53174603174603,"intelligence_score":51.95039682539682,"prose_score":52.08101851851853,"overall_score":51.795884315632705,"human_score":53.74088082587814,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":43.40277777777778,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":43.166666666666664,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":39.52777777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":38.916666666666664,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":38.375,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":38.08333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":35.25,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":63.13888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":61.11111111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":59.16666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":48.05555555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":44.763888888888886,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":43.75,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":43.666666666666664,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":81.56944444444446,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":71.16666666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":45.54166666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":41.18055555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":37.19444444444445,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":35.83333333333334,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":0.7,"price_out":1.4,"price_source":"live","blended_price":1.0297659403176371,"value_score":51.66849908197832,"writer_cost":0.9186696486,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":1026.0429685159816,"low":965.5259295301421,"high":1086.560007501821,"votes":121,"wins":60,"losses":51,"ties":10,"win_rate":53.71900826446281,"provisional":false}},{"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813","provider":"DeepSeek","run_id":"85be0a3d1bb073ed","finished_at":"2026-10-15T03:32:58.920+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":58.74,"ai_low":56.6,"ai_high":60.650000000000006,"story_score":54.208333333333336,"intelligence_score":64.00595238095238,"prose_score":60.28009259259259,"overall_score":51.60886533576663,"human_score":45.59805377830593,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":57.51388888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":55.83333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":55.68055555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":55.41666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":54.75,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":53.25,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":47.01388888888889,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":74.34722222222221,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":73.83333333333334,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":69.75,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":60.652777777777786,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":57.625,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":56.166666666666664,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":55.666666666666664,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":75.34722222222223,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":66.09722222222223,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":58.93055555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":57.43055555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":55.3888888888889,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":48.486111111111114,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":0.111,"price_out":4.4399999999999995,"price_source":"live","blended_price":2.0038190654384005,"value_score":48.59028029170485,"writer_cost":1.674726947487,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":969.3327478608352,"low":909.4358015401133,"high":1029.229694181557,"votes":124,"wins":48,"losses":60,"ties":16,"win_rate":45.16129032258064,"provisional":false}},{"model":"meta/muse-glimmer-30b","provider":"Meta","run_id":"ffe1152866fe7d65","finished_at":"2026-10-15T08:51:13.974+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":57.57,"ai_low":55.199999999999996,"ai_high":59.75,"story_score":51.66468253968254,"intelligence_score":61.95039682539682,"prose_score":63.571759259259245,"overall_score":50.18326905924855,"human_score":43.78257585712502,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"World Building","score":53.666666666666664,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":53.18055555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":52.48611111111111,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":51.416666666666664,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":50.791666666666664,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":50.263888888888886,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":49.84722222222223,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":70.06944444444444,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":69.63888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":67.19444444444444,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":65.16666666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":57.861111111111114,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":52.8888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":50.83333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":84.29166666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":75.04166666666666,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":60.22222222222222,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":55.861111111111114,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":54.68055555555555,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":51.33333333333333,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":0.3,"price_out":1.2,"price_source":"live","blended_price":0.681418809103502,"value_score":51.84912788760622,"writer_cost":0.4843913778,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":956.5721465001089,"low":896.6658807854233,"high":1016.4784122147946,"votes":125,"wins":49,"losses":66,"ties":10,"win_rate":43.2,"provisional":false}},{"model":"aion-labs/aion-2.0","provider":"AionLabs","run_id":"2e4fd9202cad8ae1","finished_at":"2026-10-14T23:50:49.742+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":43.89,"ai_low":41.550000000000004,"ai_high":45.949999999999996,"story_score":37.04960317460318,"intelligence_score":48.36309523809524,"prose_score":49.25925925925926,"overall_score":50.143189269859185,"human_score":53.066139964756495,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":40.80555555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":40,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":37.236111111111114,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":37.083333333333336,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":35.91666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":35.01388888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":33.291666666666664,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":60.736111111111114,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":55.30555555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":55.027777777777786,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":47.30555555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":41.58333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":39.916666666666664,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":38.666666666666664,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":81.06944444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":66.97222222222221,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":41.58333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":38.34722222222222,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":34.65277777777778,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":32.93055555555556,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":0.7999999999999999,"price_out":1.5999999999999999,"price_source":"live","blended_price":1.1203065524741707,"value_score":49.64982050894869,"writer_cost":0.79762122,"writer_cost_complete":true,"human":{"rating":1021.3324897211578,"low":961.1464743542558,"high":1081.5185050880598,"votes":122,"wins":60,"losses":53,"ties":9,"win_rate":52.86885245901639,"provisional":false}},{"model":"qwen/qwen3.8-flash","provider":"Qwen","run_id":"36e691fe44ce1e32","finished_at":"2026-10-19T20:29:08.727+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":true,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":56.82,"ai_low":54.2,"ai_high":59.65,"story_score":55.66269841269841,"intelligence_score":61.94642857142857,"prose_score":53.956018518518526,"overall_score":46.225650920529745,"human_score":38.124155855203895,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":58.84722222222223,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":57.29166666666666,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":56.81944444444444,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":56.58333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":55.70833333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":54.38888888888889,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":50,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":73.18055555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":70.41666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":68.91666666666667,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":60.513888888888886,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":55,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":54.58333333333333,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":51.013888888888886,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":62.31944444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":57.68055555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":54.81944444444444,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":52.527777777777786,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":50.13888888888889,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":46.25,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":0.15,"price_out":0.47,"price_source":"live","blended_price":0.3938090529645695,"value_score":50.272793964840744,"writer_cost":0.88102495404,"writer_cost_complete":false,"human":{"rating":915.871639778461,"low":855.2108808820788,"high":976.5323986748433,"votes":127,"wins":38,"losses":69,"ties":20,"win_rate":37.79527559055118,"provisional":false}},{"model":"mistralai/mistral-large-4-0","provider":"Mistral","run_id":"d806304d6f6bb503","finished_at":"2026-10-14T23:49:21.762+00:00","completed_stories":20,"expected_stories":20,"partial":false,"content_check":false,"manual_responses":0,"ai_score":44.76,"ai_low":42.9,"ai_high":46.75,"story_score":41.873015873015866,"intelligence_score":51.02380952380952,"prose_score":43.92824074074074,"overall_score":43.87087552813922,"human_score":41.80997993666944,"overall_provisional":false,"criteria":[{"criterion":"Emotionally Engaging","score":45.77777777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Compelling Plot","score":45.513888888888886,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"World Building","score":43.833333333333336,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Unsurprising or Uncreative","score":41.361111111111114,"inverted":true,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Nuanced Characters","score":40.888888888888886,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Genre Craft","score":40.236111111111114,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Believable Character Actions","score":35.5,"inverted":false,"group":"story"},{"criterion":"Followed Chapter Plan","score":65.30555555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Faithful to Writing Prompt","score":64.15277777777777,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Characters Consistent with Profile","score":60.97222222222222,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Well-earned Lightness or Darkness","score":45.80555555555556,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Pacing","score":45.25,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Coherent","score":38.59722222222223,"inverted":false,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Unearned Transformations","score":37.08333333333333,"inverted":true,"group":"intelligence"},{"criterion":"Purple Prose","score":55.27777777777778,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Show-Don't-Tell","score":48.722222222222214,"inverted":false,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Forced Poetry or Metaphor","score":47.138888888888886,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Weak Dialogue","score":40.29166666666667,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Amateurish","score":37.15277777777778,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"},{"criterion":"Slop","score":34.986111111111114,"inverted":true,"group":"prose"}],"price_in":0.7,"price_out":2.0999999999999996,"price_source":"live","blended_price":1.6392703393413621,"value_score":41.72436971908086,"writer_cost":4.2991336377,"writer_cost_complete":false,"human":{"rating":942.5725808848174,"low":882.5621080027884,"high":1002.5830537668464,"votes":126,"wins":45,"losses":67,"ties":14,"win_rate":41.269841269841265,"provisional":false}}]